A look at how intimate partner violence can lead to intimate partner homicide.


3 min read

Jason Brien.

Intimate partner violence is domestic violence. It is any type of abuse which occurs within the confines of personal and intimate relationship between two or more people (monogamous and polygamous relationships). Intimate partner homicide is when one of the intimate partners is killed by the other intimate partner. The majority of intimate partner violence/homicide research is centred around violence/homicide which occurs male to female or female to male. Unfortunately, there is a lack of research centred around same sex couples and their experiences of intimate partner violence/homicide.

Of all the research that does exist, in both straight relationships and same sex relationships, the findings have suggested that the strongest or most common risk factor for intimate partner homicide is previous and/or ongoing domestic abuse. Dr Jane Monckton Smith in particular examined the deaths of 575 women and concluded that 372 of the women had been killed by their intimate partner (either current or former). Dr Smith found that within straight relationships, 80% of intimate partner homicide victims were women thus making the vast majority of perpetrators male. Dr Smith discovered an 8-stage pattern which was present in all 372 killings.

Stage 1: Pre relationship history; All of the perpetrators responsible for the deaths of the women examined had a prior history of domestic violence, prior history of accusations of domestic violence, controlling behaviours and/or a criminal record. 

Stage 2 : Early relationship behaviours; The perpetrators all displayed signs of early commitment. They either encouraged cohabitation very early, encouraged pregnancy very early or made a marriage proposal very soon after the relationship commenced. They were also very quick to make declarations of love using words and phrases such as “mine”, “you’re my soul mate” or “we will be together for ever”. 

Stage 3: Relationship behaviours/red flags; The perpetrators had a tendency to engage in the following behaviours - coercive control, stalking (even low level like going through bag, phone, etc), possessiveness, violence (even low level like shoving or breaking things), threats of suicide or homicide, forced isolation from family and friends, drug and/or alcohol problems and more. 

Stage 4: Impending homicide warning signs; Threat of, or actual separation or divorce, division of assets, financial problems (debts, bankruptcy), unemployment, perpetrator or victim’s mental or physical health deteriorates, events which might engender ‘revenge’ (e.g., a real or imagined affair by the victim).

Stage 5: Escalation warning signs; Concerning behaviours become more frequent, serious or severe. Threats to kill victims, children, family or pets. Threats of suicide. Possessive use of language “you can never leave me”, “we will die together”, or “I won’t let you leave with my kids”. 

Stage 6: Change in thinking warning signs; Perpetrator’s last attempts at reconciliation. Victim begins new relationship, stops contact with perpetrator or moves away. Perpetrator is facing financial disaster (starts considering insurance payouts), their mental or physical health is quickly and irreversibly deteriorating or their perceived status is diminished. 

Stage 7: Planning homicide warning signs; Sudden changes in usual behaviour. Withdraw suddenly or become unusually menacing. High level stalking (monitoring GPS, listening devices, google searches, etc). Collecting, making or purchasing weapons. May tell others of their homicidal plans or make subtle hints (“soon all my problems will be over”). 

Stage 8: Characteristics of the homicide; Clear homicide with confession, Homicide with suicide of offender, made to look like suicide or mercy killing. Made to look like accident, natural causes or self-defence. Stage missing persons. Contact media. Appeal to public. Participate in searches, etc. I find the murder of Shanann Watts and her three young children quite interesting within the context of Dr Smith’s 8 stage pattern. Based on what has been reported and released in the media or by the authorities, Shanann’s husband, the perpetrator does not fit all of the 8 stages neatly or in order. The perpetrator had no significant prior relationship to speak of so there is no evidence of prior domestic violence. The perpetrator was however dominated by strong women (first his mother then Shanann) which may have curbed his natural desires to control and dominate. Shanann also appeared to be controlling and possessive as she controlled the money (the family was heavily in debt). 

Shanann disliked the perpetrators family and sought to isolate the children from their grandparents on that side of the family. There is no evidence that the perpetrator sought to isolate Shanann or the children. There is no evidence that the perpetrator directly stalked Shanann in any way (perhaps via Nichol Kessinger but that is highly debatable). It is hard to tell where the perpetrator enters the 8-stage pattern. The perpetrator could come in as early as stage 2 as he did pursue Shanann quite strongly at the start of the relationship. There is not much evidence for stage 3. He may come in at stage 4 if he perceived Shanann’s controlling behaviours as something to seek revenge against or if he saw the children were a ‘ploy’ used by Shanann to ‘trap’ him. 

There is only slight evidence for stage 5. On the night of the killing, Shanann confronted the perpetrator about his affair and allegedly stated that he would not see or have access to their children. Stage 6 seems to be when he started his affair and began to contemplate a life with his new lover and without his current (now former) wife and/or children. Stage 7 is where his actions become more identifiable with the 8-stage pattern. Again, there is no indication that he directly staked Shanann but he clearly started to formulate some kind of plan to eliminate his wife and/or children. Stage 8 is obvious to all who are familiar with the case.

Resources.

https://www.womensaid.ie/assets/files/pdf/jane_monckton_smith_powerpoint_2018_compatibility_mode.pdf?fbclid=IwAR14ko0vmq9kNKQa9ssJo16wWKkDt77YdOgCmfIJy7F5zFvuFz9TLB_e7ao

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3384540/

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1447915/

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01506/full

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watts_family_murders